Historic building rehabilitation tax credit explained

Historic building tax credits: A complete guide

In an era where urban renewal and historic preservation intersect with smart financial planning, the Historic Building Rehabilitation Tax Credit has emerged as a powerful tool for property developers, investors, and preservationists alike. As cities across America seek to revitalize their historic districts while preserving their architectural heritage, understanding how to leverage these valuable tax incentives has become increasingly important. This comprehensive guide will walk you through everything you need to know about breathing new life into historic properties while maximizing your tax benefits.

Understanding the historic building rehabilitation tax credit

The Historic Building Rehabilitation Tax Credit, commonly known as the Historic Tax Credit (HTC), represents one of the federal government's most significant investments in historic preservation. Administered through a partnership between the National Park Service, the Internal Revenue Service, and State Historic Preservation Offices, this program offers a substantial 20% tax credit on qualified rehabilitation expenses for certified historic structures.

This credit serves multiple purposes beyond simple tax savings. It has become a crucial tool for urban revitalization, helping to transform abandoned or underutilized historic buildings into vibrant spaces that contribute to community development. The program's success lies in its ability to make historic preservation economically viable while ensuring that rehabilitation work meets high standards of historical authenticity.

Unlike many other tax benefits, the HTC provides a dollar-for-dollar reduction in federal income taxes, making it particularly valuable for developers and investors. The credit's transferability adds another layer of flexibility, allowing project developers to monetize the credit even if they don't have sufficient tax liability themselves. This feature has made the HTC a cornerstone of many complex real estate development financing structures.

Qualifying for the historic tax credit

The qualification process for the Historic Tax Credit involves several critical components that must be carefully considered before embarking on a rehabilitation project. Understanding these requirements in detail can help ensure your project's success from both a preservation and financial perspective.

Building eligibility requirements

The first crucial step in pursuing the historic tax credit is confirming your building's eligibility. A qualifying structure must hold historic significance, which can be established through two primary paths. The building may be individually listed in the National Register of Historic Places, which recognizes properties of exceptional historical or architectural importance. Alternatively, the structure might be located within a registered historic district and certified as contributing to that district's historical significance.

The building's intended use plays a crucial role in eligibility. The tax credit program is specifically designed for income-producing properties, which can include commercial spaces, offices, hotels, industrial facilities, or rental housing. This requirement aligns with the program's goal of encouraging economic development alongside historic preservation. However, it's important to note that owner-occupied residential properties do not qualify for the federal credit, though some state programs may offer incentives for such properties.

The rehabilitation work must also meet the "substantial rehabilitation" test. This means that the cost of rehabilitation must exceed the greater of $5,000 or the building's adjusted basis. The adjusted basis is generally the purchase price, minus the cost of land, plus improvements already made, minus depreciation already taken. This requirement ensures that projects receiving the credit involve significant investment in preserving and improving historic structures.

The application process

Successfully navigating the application process requires careful attention to detail and thorough documentation throughout your project's development. Understanding each phase of the application process can help you avoid common pitfalls and ensure your project meets all necessary requirements.

Initial evaluation of significance

The first formal step in the process involves submitting Form 10-168: Part 1 to the National Park Service through your State Historic Preservation Office. This submission documents your building's historic significance and its eligibility for the credit program. Your application should include comprehensive documentation of the building's history, architectural significance, and its role in the broader context of local or national history. Historic photographs, architectural drawings, and detailed descriptions of the building's character-defining features all play important roles in establishing historic significance.

Description of rehabilitation work

Once your building's historic significance is established, the next phase involves submitting detailed plans for the proposed rehabilitation work. This submission must demonstrate how your planned renovations will preserve the building's historic character while adapting it for contemporary use. Your application should include architectural drawings, specifications, and photographs that clearly show existing conditions and planned modifications.

The rehabilitation plan must adhere to the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation, which provide guidelines for appropriately modifying historic buildings. These standards emphasize preserving significant historic features while allowing for reasonable changes to accommodate new uses. Your submission should explain how your proposed work meets these standards and addresses any potential concerns about historic preservation.

Certification of completed work

The final phase of the application process occurs after the rehabilitation work is complete. This submission documents how the completed work follows the approved rehabilitation plan and meets preservation standards. Detailed photographs of the completed work, final cost certification, and documentation of any changes from the approved plan are essential components of this submission.

Qualified rehabilitation expenses

Understanding what constitutes a qualified rehabilitation expense can significantly impact your project's financial success. These expenses form the basis for calculating your tax credit, making it crucial to track and document them properly.

Eligible costs

Qualified rehabilitation expenses encompass a wide range of costs directly related to the rehabilitation of the historic structure. Construction costs typically form the largest category, including expenses for repairing or replacing historic features, upgrading building systems, and ensuring structural stability. Professional fees for architects, engineers, and preservation consultants can also qualify, as can development fees and construction period interest.

The key to qualifying expenses lies in their direct relationship to the rehabilitation of the historic structure. Work must be capital in nature, rather than ordinary repair or maintenance, and must be depreciable under IRS rules. This means the improvements must have a useful life of more than one year and be part of the income-producing property.

Ineligible costs

Some expenses, though necessary for project completion, do not qualify for the tax credit. The acquisition cost of the building itself is explicitly excluded, as are costs for new additions or enlargements that expand the historic structure's footprint. Site improvements such as landscaping, parking lots, and sidewalks also fall outside the scope of qualified rehabilitation expenses. Understanding these distinctions early in the planning process can help you accurately project the available tax credit and structure your financing accordingly.

‍

Calculating the credit

Understanding the calculation and timing of the historic tax credit is crucial for proper financial planning of your rehabilitation project. While the basic calculation is straightforward – 20% of qualified rehabilitation expenses – the rules around credit utilization and transferability require careful consideration.

The 20% Credit Calculation

When calculating your potential tax credit, begin with your total qualified rehabilitation expenses. These expenses must be carefully documented and must directly relate to the rehabilitation of the historic structure. For example, if your qualified rehabilitation expenses total $2,000,000, your potential tax credit would be $400,000.

The Internal Revenue Service requires the credit to be claimed over a five-year period, with 20% of the total credit amount claimed each year. For instance, with a $400,000 total credit, you would claim $80,000 per year for five years. This structured approach helps ensure long-term commitment to maintaining the building's historic character while providing predictable tax benefits over time.

Credit Transferability

Following changes implemented by the Inflation Reduction Act of 2022, historic tax credits became directly transferable for tax years beginning after December 31, 2022. This significant change simplified the process of monetizing credits, eliminating the need for complex partnership structures that were previously required to transfer credits.

Property owners now have the option to either:

‍

Use the credits directly against their own tax liability over the five-year period

Transfer (sell) the credits to other taxpayers who can utilize them

Maintain traditional partnership structures if they align better with overall project goals

‍

This enhanced flexibility in credit transferability has made historic rehabilitation projects more attractive to a broader range of developers and investors, potentially increasing the feasibility of many preservation projects.

‍

State historic tax credits

While the federal historic tax credit provides significant benefits, many states have recognized the value of historic preservation and established their own complementary programs. These state-level credits can substantially enhance the financial feasibility of rehabilitation projects, sometimes making the difference between a project that moves forward and one that remains on the drawing board.

State credits vary significantly in their structure and requirements. Some states offer credits as high as 50% of qualified rehabilitation expenses, while others might provide more modest incentives. Many states have established annual caps on available credits, creating competition among projects and requiring careful timing of applications. Understanding your state's specific program requirements and application deadlines is essential for maximizing your potential tax benefits.

For example, Georgia offers a state historic tax credit of up to 25% of qualified rehabilitation expenses, which can be combined with the federal credit. Maryland provides a competitive commercial credit of up to 20% of qualified rehabilitation expenditures, with additional incentives for projects in opportunity zones. These state programs often have their own specific requirements and compliance procedures that must be followed in addition to the federal guidelines.

Project planning and implementation

Successful historic rehabilitation projects require meticulous planning and careful implementation. The complexity of these projects demands a comprehensive approach that begins long before any physical work starts and continues well after construction is complete.

Early planning phase

The early planning phase of your historic rehabilitation project sets the foundation for success. Begin by thoroughly researching your building's history and significance. This research should include not only the architectural elements but also the building's role in the community's development. Understanding this history will inform your rehabilitation decisions and strengthen your tax credit application.

During this phase, assemble your project team. This should include professionals experienced in historic preservation projects, such as architects familiar with the Secretary of the Interior's Standards, contractors who have worked with historic buildings, and consultants who understand the tax credit application process. Your team might also include historic preservation specialists, structural engineers, and financial advisors who can help navigate the complexities of project financing.

Implementation and compliance

As you move into the implementation phase, maintaining strict compliance with approved plans becomes crucial. Any changes to the approved rehabilitation plan must be reviewed and approved by the appropriate authorities before implementation. This might seem burdensome, but it helps ensure your project maintains its eligibility for tax credits and meets preservation standards.

Document everything during construction. Photograph all phases of work, keep detailed records of materials used, and maintain clear documentation of any decisions made during the rehabilitation process. This documentation serves multiple purposes: it supports your final certification application, provides evidence of compliance with standards, and creates a valuable record for future maintenance and rehabilitation work.

Financial structuring and partnerships

The financial structure of historic rehabilitation projects often involves multiple funding sources and complex partnerships. Understanding how to effectively combine these various elements can significantly impact your project's success.

Financing sources

Traditional debt financing typically forms the foundation of most historic rehabilitation projects, but the unique nature of these projects often requires additional funding sources. Historic tax credit equity can provide a significant portion of project funding, either through direct investment or syndication. Many developers partner with tax credit investors who provide upfront capital in exchange for the future tax credits.

Additional funding might come from new market tax credits, energy efficiency incentives, or local economic development programs. Some communities offer facade improvement grants or tax increment financing that can be combined with historic tax credits. Successfully layering these various funding sources requires careful planning and often specialized legal and financial expertise.

Partnership structures

Many historic rehabilitation projects utilize partnership structures to optimize the use of tax credits. These structures typically involve the property owner forming a partnership or limited liability company with a tax credit investor. The partnership must be carefully structured to comply with IRS requirements while meeting the business objectives of all parties involved.

Common partnership structures include the single-tier structure, where the tax credit investor becomes a direct partner in the property-owning entity, and the master tenant structure, which involves creating a separate entity to lease and operate the property. Each structure has its advantages and complications, and the choice depends on various factors including project size, investor preferences, and specific state credit requirements.

Long-term management and compliance

Successfully completing your historic rehabilitation project and claiming the tax credits is not the end of your obligations. Understanding and planning for long-term management and compliance requirements is essential for maintaining your tax credit benefits.

Recapture period

The federal historic tax credit comes with a five-year recapture period, during which certain actions can trigger a repayment requirement. These triggering events might include selling the building, changing its use to a non-qualifying purpose, or making unauthorized alterations that compromise its historic character. During this period, maintain detailed records of any changes to the property and consult with preservation professionals before making any significant alterations.

Ongoing maintenance

Proper maintenance of your rehabilitated historic building serves multiple purposes. It helps preserve the historic character that qualifies the building for tax credits, protects your investment, and can prevent costly repairs in the future. Develop a comprehensive maintenance plan that addresses both routine upkeep and long-term preservation needs. This plan should include regular inspections, preventive maintenance schedules, and protocols for addressing any issues that arise.

Future opportunities and industry trends

The field of historic rehabilitation continues to evolve, presenting new opportunities and challenges for developers and investors. Understanding current trends and future directions can help you position your projects for success.

Sustainable development

Historic rehabilitation increasingly intersects with sustainable development practices. Many developers are finding innovative ways to incorporate energy-efficient systems and sustainable materials while preserving historic character. This trend aligns with growing market demand for environmentally responsible properties and can provide access to additional incentives and funding sources.

Market adaptation

The way historic buildings are being adapted for modern use continues to evolve. Mixed-use developments have become increasingly popular, allowing historic buildings to serve multiple functions while creating vibrant community spaces. The growth of remote work has also influenced rehabilitation projects, with many historic buildings being adapted to include flexible workspace options alongside traditional uses.

Technology integration

Advanced technology is playing an increasingly important role in historic rehabilitation projects. From 3D scanning and modeling tools that aid in documentation and planning, to smart building systems that enhance operational efficiency, technology is helping make historic buildings more functional while preserving their character.

Strategic planning with Instead

Navigating the complexities of historic rehabilitation tax credits requires careful planning and expert guidance. Instead's advanced tax planning platform can help you optimize your tax strategy around historic rehabilitation projects while ensuring compliance with all applicable regulations. Visit Instead.com to learn more about how our innovative solutions can support your historic rehabilitation projects and overall tax planning needs.